On this episode of Talking Buffalo, Patrick Moran takes a break from Buffalo sports talk to unveil his personal rankings for the Top 10 wing spots in Western New York for 2026. From legendary staples like Bar-Bill Tavern and Nine-Eleven Tavern to rising favorites like Belt Line Brewery and Main & Hamlin, Patrick breaks down what makes each destination special—including sauces, crispiness, consistency, atmosphere and overall experience.
He also reflects on recent live podcast episodes featuring Cami Clune and Thad Brown, plus shares strong opinions on blue cheese, dive bars and the culture surrounding Buffalo wings.
Whether you’re a lifelong Buffalonian or planning your first wing trip to Western New York, this episode is packed with passionate food takes, local flavor and plenty of debate-worthy rankings.
Key Takeaways
- Patrick reveals his full Top 10 wing rankings for Western New York in 2026
- Nine-Eleven Tavern earns the top spot thanks to consistency and classic Buffalo-style wings
- Wingnutz sparks debate as one of Buffalo’s most polarizing wing spots
- Belt Line Brewery is labeled the biggest riser on Patrick’s rankings
- Patrick emphasizes that Buffalo’s wing scene is more about celebration than competition
Timestamps / Chapters
- 00:00 – Introduction & why this became the perfect time for a wing rankings episode
- 08:30 – Honorable mentions including Imperial Pizza, Macy’s Place Pizzeria and Transit Music Lounge
- 15:00 – Breaking down No. 10 through No. 6, including Forty Thieves and Elmo’s Restaurant & Bar
- 33:00 – Why Sonny Red’s and Belt Line Brewery have become elite wing destinations
- 43:00 – The final showdown between Bar-Bill Tavern and Nine-Eleven Tavern
Today’s episode is brought to you by the law offices of William Mattar. Hurt in a car, call William Mattar. 444-4444. Call William Mattar today to get the compensation you deserve.
The Talking Buffalo online merch store is now live! You can purchase t shirts, hoodies, zip ups, crewnecks and polos in a couple of different styles and colors. Visit our online page for pricing and options and while there, check out Buf on Weck for tons of cool gear!
Please be sure to subscribe to Talking Buffalo on the audio side, even if you usually watch the show via YouTube. Several of the links to follow Talking Buffalo can be found right here.
Also if you’re not yet subscribed to Talking Buffalo on YouTube, please do so and be sure to hit the LIKE button on the videos, it really helps with the algorithm!
♦♦♦♦♦
Follow Patrick Moran/Talking Buffalo Podcast
Substack: Patrick Moran’s Substack
Twitter: @PatrickMoranTB
Blue Sky: @PatrickMoranTB.bsky.social
Instagram: @PatrickMoranTB
Facebook: Talking Buffalo Podcast